I did it. I broke down and got Sega’s NFL game, ESPN 2K5. I needed a game to play on my girlfriend’s PS2 since I got stuck on Simpsons Hit And Run. She’s gotten better than me at Tetris so I needed something new. I also wanted to have a football presence at her house. Getting another NCAA Football for PS2 since I had one for the Xbox seemed foolish. The $20 price and rave reviews made ESPN 2K5 hard to pass up.
I’m not going to tell you this game is perfect. I’m not going to tell you it’s better than Madden, especially since I haven’t seen what EA is bringing to the table this year. But I will tell you this: you will get more good football in this game for your money than anywhere else. Yeah, NCAA 2005 is good, and Madden may even be better. But those games are $50. For less than half that price, I bet this game is just about as good.
Johnny and I played last year’s model and were not impressed. The passing game was pathetic and we quickly lost interest, preferring to return to the superior playability of EA goodness. That was last year. This is this year.
This year, the gameplay is pretty respectable, and it was fun being able to actually catch passes. In my Week 1 matchup against the Jets (I’m the Bengals, of course) Carson Palmer completed more passes than Gino Guidugli (”QB #8″ to those of you who haven’t modified all the names) did in an entire season of NCAA! The graphics aren’t as polished as the competition’s, but the presentation is fantastic. Lots of great touches make you feel like you’re watching an NFL game on ESPN. You can even check out a brief Sportscenter complete with a few highlights after you play. Between games you can choose what your team does each and every day for practice. The scouting information is unreal, almost too much. Another positive that EA has GOT to pick up on is you can control the length of simulated games. It’s very frustrating to find your players punished because when you play five minute quarters, everyone else is getting three times as many snaps as you. Your best defensive player ends up with 45 tackles a season, not even ranked in the top 100 in that category. It’s a great feature cause you can compare your team straight up with the rest of the league, and not apples to oranges.
One thing that did bother me that I noticed in the NBA version, too, is that the game gets a little loosey-goosey with trades. Over the course of a season, Tracy McGrady ended up with the Pacers. And in this game, the Chargers traded LaDanien Tomlinson for Hines Ward. Not before the season, not after preseason, but right after Week 1. After Week 2, Quentin Jammer and Vonnie Holiday changed teams. Way too much going on after the season starts. I don’t mind the computer making trades, but this kind of blockbuster really takes you out of the game and out of the world they spend so much time trying to create.
They try some things that need some polishing. The interface is still goofy, too much work to do some basic things and too easy to leave the game without vital info getting saved. Chris Berman at the desk looks weird and so does Suzy Kolber interviewing the player of the game. Another thing that really bothered me was the announcer. I was dissapointed they didn’t get Mike Patrick, Joe Theisman, and Paul McGuire to complete the ESPN package. The fellows they replace them with are professional broadcasters, but I would not have gone with that play-by-play guy. He’s got a nasal-ly AM Radio news voice that gets old after three seconds. I can only imagine how grating it would be after a whole season.
One audio plus is the NFL Primetime background music is present on this disc. Unfortunately, no “air raid siren” song they use to promote their Sunday night telecasts. If they did have that music, that alone would have been worth the $20 for me. I have not had any lucky finding that anywhere. (HINT: you will make me very happy if you tell me where I can get my hands on that song.)
Again, haven’t seen what Madden will bring, but he’s got his work cut out for him. ESPN 2K5 has raised the bar high. Of course, Madden has the built in advantage of NCAA proving feeder characters for continued career gameplay. But if ESPN had a college football game equivelant, watch out. They have made up a lot of ground quickly.
“I heard their periods attract bears!”