Last week, I really complimented the Star Wars fans. They seem to have produced the most fan films out there. By and large, the overall quality seems to be the best. So I wanted to take a look at how fans of other franchises fared in comparison. My first thought was to go to Star Wars main rival, Star Trek. As far as a fan film communty goes, this doesn’t fare too well. The only place with multiple movie listings I saw was this About Star Trek fan films page. Maybe the lack of product is a result of Viacom’s aggressive protection of their property. A few attempts to carry on Gene Roddenberry’s vision seem to have gotten past the crackdown. Like the previously reviewed Star Trek: New Voyages, this is an ongoing production of original episodes that seem to take place after Deep Space Nine’s run ended.
FF type: Series
Currently, they are in the middle of their sixth season of shows. The episode runs are smaller than their network counterparts, but it’s still an impressive library they’ve compiled. I went to watch the very first episode, when a window opened up requesting I actually begin with their season six premiere so they could put their “best foot forward.” As per their request, that is the episode reviewed here.
Production Quality: (4) If you ever saw an episode of Star Trek and really wished those ships did more than just float out in space, this is for you. There is an all-out battle that rages here between dozen of Federation and bad guy ships. Those effects might even be better than the ones on the TV shows. It ain’t too bad inside the ships, either. Almost every scene involving humans is shot in front of a green screen. There’s emerald halo around everyone, but it’s negligible considering how much this saves them from having to build sets. It does, however, make it confusing at times to figure out who’s where and on what ship or station.
Performances: (1) Lots of amateurs. Some of them have accents so bad you can’t understand what they’re saying. Some don’t even have the basica acting ability to look at the person they’re yelling at. Others… well, gosh, how do I say this politely? I don’t expect to find pretty people on fan films, especially if they’re not professionally casted. But there ain’t a lot of these people who has the on-screen presence to overcome their non-prettyness. And another horribly rude observation: I thought Star Fleet had fitness regulations. Sure, Ryker develloped a bit of a gut, but he didn’t have to shop at the Big and Tall Captain’s store. They also recast a character once played by Ashley Judd. Yeah, you ain’t got anyone who can pass themselves off as her.
Fan quotient: (1) The casting can be forgiven, but this category cannot. Not only is there way too much stuff for non-Star Trek fans to absorb, but this show has develloped it’s own mythology that is crucial to understand what is going on. Like I said, I started at the season 6 premiere and it might as well have been season 66. I was lost from the very beginning and hadn’t caught up by the end of the episode.
Entertainment Value: (2) There’s too much Trek babble to wade through to find this worth watching unless you have been a big fan of the shows. The space battles are very impressive and definitely the highlight of the episode.
FF obtainment: (4) Episodes can be downloaded at Hidden Frontier. If I’m reading this right, some are also available for podcasts… whatever that means.
Star Trek: Hidden Frontier: 12 out of 25.
Yeah, harsh score. But this is very specifically targetted at hardcore Star Trek fans willing to spend hours in front of their computers watching this new show. There is nothing on the site that acts as a summary and there’s no exposition preceding the episode, or even during it, to brief the viewer on important details. They’ve got a pretty decent product, now they need to work on reaching out to the casual fan and educating them about this hidden frontier and why we should care about it.
“We need breathing room!”
“Earth. Hitler. 1938″
* Yeah, yeah, I know it’s not really Friday.